EWA A. ŁUKASZYK
  • Home
  • ABOUT
  • THEORY & EXPERIMENTS
    • BEYOND TRANSMISSION
    • DESERT
    • EROTICISM OF TRACE
    • INTIMATE MICROSPHERES
    • NON-CULTURAL MORPHOGENESIS
    • PINWHEELS
    • POETICS OF THE VOID
    • SYMBOLIC MATRIX
  • RESEARCH & PROJECTS
    • DISCIPLINES >
      • LITERARY THEORY
      • COMPARATIVE LITERATURE
      • GLOBAL LITERARY STUDIES
      • HISTORY OF IDEAS
      • CULTURAL THEORY & ANALYSIS
    • AREAS >
      • ISLAMIC STUDIES
      • ARAB LITERATURE
      • MAGHREBIAN & WEST AFRICAN STUDIES
      • WEST EUROPEAN & EURO-MEDITERRANEAN LITERATURES
      • EAST EUROPEAN & POST-SOVIET LITERATURES
      • PORTUGUESE STUDIES
      • LUSOPHONE AFRICAN STUDIES
      • LATIN AMERICAN STUDIES
    • PERIODS >
      • MEDIEVAL & EARLY MODERN STUDIES
      • 19TH-CENTURY STUDIES
    • FIELDS >
      • TRANSCULTURAL HUMANITIES
      • TRANSCOLONIAL & TRANSINDIGENOUS STUDIES
      • MARITIME HUMANITIES
      • FEMINISMS, GENDER & QUEER STUDIES
      • EROTICISM & SEXUALITY STUDIES
      • PLANT & ANIMAL STUDIES
      • APOCALYPTIC STUDIES
    • TOPICS >
      • TRAVEL WRITING
      • WRITINGS ON ART
  • LIBRARY & THE WORLD
    • ARCTIC & SCANDINAVIA >
      • GREENLAND
      • ICELAND
      • NORWAY
      • SWEDEN
      • FINLAND
      • DENMARK
    • EASTERN EUROPE >
      • ESTONIA
      • LATVIA
      • LITHUANIA
      • RUSSIA
      • BELARUS
      • UKRAINE
      • POLAND
      • Forty Years of Travel in Poland
      • CZECH REPUBLIC
      • SLOVAKIA
      • HUNGARY
      • ROMANIA
      • MOLDOVA
    • WESTERN EUROPE >
      • IRELAND
      • SCOTLAND
      • GREAT BRITAIN
      • NETHERLANDS
      • BELGIUM
      • LUXEMBURG
      • GERMANY
      • AUSTRIA
      • LIECHTENSTEIN
      • SWITZERLAND
      • FRANCE
      • MIDI
      • ITALY
      • VENICE
      • SICILY
      • MALTA
      • CATALONIA
      • SPAIN
      • PORTUGAL
      • CANARY ISLANDS
    • THE BALKANS >
      • SLOVENIA
      • CROATIA
      • SERBIA
      • ALBANIA
      • BOSNIA & HERZEGOVINA
      • MONTENEGRO
      • BULGARIA
      • NORTH MACEDONIA
      • GREECE
    • CAUCASUS >
      • GEORGIA
      • ARMENIA
      • AZERBAIJAN
      • CHECHNYA & INGUSHETIA
      • DAGESTAN
      • A Ride across the Caucasus
    • MIDDLE EAST >
      • EGYPT
      • LEBANON
      • PALESTINE
      • ISRAEL
      • CYPRUS
      • TURKEY
      • CAPPADOCIA
      • KURDISTAN
      • SYRIA
      • IRAQ
      • KUWAIT
      • JORDAN
      • SAUDI ARABIA
      • QATAR
      • UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
      • BAHRAIN
      • OMAN
      • YEMEN
    • MAGHREB & SAHEL >
      • AL-ANDALUS
      • MOROCCO
      • TUNISIA
      • ALGERIA
      • LIBYA
      • SAHRAWI REPUBLIC
      • MAURITANIA
      • MALI
      • BURKINA FASO
      • NIGER
      • CHAD
      • SUDAN
      • FULANI WORLD
      • MANDINGA WORLD
    • WEST AFRICA >
      • SENEGAL
      • GAMBIA
      • CAPE VERDE
      • GUINEA-BISSAU
      • GUINEA
      • SIERRA LEONE
      • IVORY COAST
      • GHANA
      • SAO TOME & PRINCIPE
      • TOGO
      • BENIN
      • NIGERIA
      • CAMEROON
      • EQUATORIAL GUINEA
      • CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC
      • GABON
    • THE HORN OF AFRICA >
      • ETHIOPIA
      • ERITREA
      • DJIBOUTI
      • SOMALIA
    • THE SOUTH OF AFRICA >
      • CONGO
      • UGANDA
      • KENYA
      • RWANDA
      • BURUNDI
      • TANZANIA
      • ANGOLA
      • ZAMBIA
      • MALAWI
      • MOZAMBIQUE
      • ZIMBABWE
      • NAMIBIA
      • BOTSWANA
      • SOUTH AFRICA
      • LESOTHO
      • ESWATINI
    • INDIA & INDIAN OCEAN >
      • INDIA
      • NEPAL
      • BHUTAN
      • BANGLADESH
      • SRI LANKA
      • MALDIVES
      • SEYCHELLES
      • MAURITIUS
      • COMOROS
      • MADAGASCAR
    • SOUTH EAST ASIA >
      • LAOS
      • VIETNAM
      • CAMBODIA
      • MYANMAR
      • THAILAND
      • MALAYSIA
      • SINGAPORE
      • BRUNEI
      • INDONESIA
      • BALI
      • TIMOR
      • PHILIPPINES
    • IRAN & CENTRAL ASIA >
      • IRAN
      • AFGHANISTAN
      • PAKISTAN
      • UZBEKISTAN
      • TAJIKISTAN
      • KYRGYZSTAN
      • TURKMENISTAN
      • KAZAKHSTAN
      • TAKLAMAKAN & THE UYGHURS
    • NORTH & NORTH EAST ASIA >
      • CHUKOTKA & KAMCHATKA
      • SAKHA (YAKUTIA)
      • JAPAN
      • MANCHURIA
      • KOREA
      • BURYATIA
      • TUVA
      • MONGOLIA
      • CHINA
      • TIBET
    • NORTH AMERICA >
      • CANADA
      • UNITED STATES
    • MESOAMERICA >
      • MEXICO
      • GUATEMALA
      • BELIZE
      • EL SALVADOR
      • HONDURAS
      • NICARAGUA
      • COSTA RICA
      • PANAMA
    • THE CARIBBEAN >
      • CUBA
      • JAMAICA
      • HAITI
      • DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
      • PUERTO RICO
      • MARTINIQUE
      • TRINIDAD & TOBAGO
    • SOUTH AMERICA >
      • BRAZIL
      • COLOMBIA
      • VENEZUELA
      • GUYANA
      • SURINAME
      • ECUADOR
      • PERU
      • BOLIVIA
      • URUGUAY
      • PARAGUAY
      • ARGENTINA
      • CHILE
    • POLYNESIA >
      • EASTER ISLAND
      • TAHITI & FRENCH POLYNESIA
      • SAMOA
      • TONGA
    • MICRONESIA >
      • MARSHALL ISLANDS
      • PALAU
      • KIRIBATI
    • MELANESIA >
      • PAPUA NEW GUINEA
      • NEW CALEDONIA
      • VANUATU
      • FIJI
      • SOLOMON ISLANDS
    • AUSTRALASIA >
      • AUSTRALIA
      • NEW ZEALAND
    • ANTARCTICA >
      • EXPLORATION
  • AUTOBIOGRAPHICA & MARGINALIA
    • The Four Riders
    • The Flight of the Crimson Angel
    • Becoming undead
    • Transition
    • LIFESTYLE
    • ON LANGUAGES
    • FALCONRY
    • NATURE PHOTOGRAPHY >
      • PLANTS >
        • BOTANIC GARDENS
        • FORESTS
      • BUTTERFLIES
      • AMPHIBIANS & REPTILES
      • BIRDS
      • MAMMALS
      • WATER & AQUATIC LIFE
      • EARTH
      • LIGHT
    • GARDEN & DESERT. Erotic Journal
  • News & Events
    • Void in the making. RESEARCH BLOG
  • TEXTS
  • Contact

GARDEN & DESERT
​
Erotic Journal

All ignorance is justified

27/7/2016

0 Comments

 
ICLA 2016: THE WORLD CONGRESS OF THE INTERNATIONAL COMPARATIVE LITERATURE ASSOCIATION

I did everything wrong in this congress. I was wandering among the sessions, instead of sticking to the main panels and keynotes. And what's more, I tried to catch the most exotic ones, instead of staying close to the major literatures and major affiliations. Because unfortunately, in the current state of the world comparative literature, it's still either - or. Either you stick to the same medieval French literature, and you hear smooth, perfectly professional presentation in elegant English, or you wander in search of Gitagovinda, or mysticism, or any other exotic topic of the kind, and you hear not more than mumbling, degenerating in some moments into sheer drivel. The session on mysticism, on the last day, culminated into a detailed reading of Derrida's and Spivak's writings in terms of mystical utterances (sic!). Haven't you ever wonder why you cant understand a word of them? Because they are mystics, that's what it is!
There was a substantial Polish representation in this congress. Finally we have our own national association of comparative literature. The event provokes an answer to the eternal question concerning our place in the world humanities. Well, the level of the world is variable; you find such an enormous scale of competence, going from zero to... close to infinity? I don't think so. Overall I found relatively few brilliant and innovative ideas in this congress, in any case less than expected (David Damrosch's brilliant analysis of... the latest books' covers was symptomatic). Anyway we, Poles are somewhere in the middle, between nothing and... something of everything. The wisdom that comes to me is rather to accept stoically our own fate of insufficiency. All ignorance is justified. The clumsiness of those who tried to speak about their recitations, those at home in Kerala, as well as the learned presumption of those who could speak pertinently about the same French literature of all times, never attempting to break through their own cultural horizon.
But the Polish case, again... The coordinator of my session, a very nice German lady, commented at the end that she had been so surprised reading my abstract, it seemed so exotic to her, she said, that someone in Poland studied the literature of Angola and Mozambique... I see the reason of her surprise. I know what kind of presentations the Polish colleagues used to propose... "Polish reception of this and that" and "This and that in Poland". And strangely, I didn't say a word about Ondjaki in Poland...
Overall, I'm planning to come back for the next world congress. But in the meanwhile, I've scheduled my participation in an Orientalistentag organised by the Deutsche Morgenländische Gesellschaft, a respectful, 19th.-century association that hopefully might provide me with all what I wish to know about Gitagovindas of the world. In other words, I hope that specialised conferences may offer me what I've been missing at the great comparativist congress.
I might regret I didn't stick to the leading scholars, I didn't pay sufficient attention to affiliations, and I lost my time exploring the margins. But after all, such events are not really to gather knowledge. Their aim is to offer an insight into the global situation, to see people, not ideas. Even if, at the end, you are left alone with just yourself... David Damrosch's book, Meetings of the Mind, came back in more than one conversation. Its final lesson, after all: the whole panel of scholars is just you. I prefer another reference. The note of young Eliade in the Tivoli gardens, alone, dreaming about the crowd of discussing scholars...
The world congress with a thousand participants is perhaps an opportunity to be alone, bringing forth the essential loneliness of the scholar, helping to find one's own place in the middle of all the mess.

Picture
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    blog archives

    September 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    September 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    November 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • ABOUT
  • THEORY & EXPERIMENTS
    • BEYOND TRANSMISSION
    • DESERT
    • EROTICISM OF TRACE
    • INTIMATE MICROSPHERES
    • NON-CULTURAL MORPHOGENESIS
    • PINWHEELS
    • POETICS OF THE VOID
    • SYMBOLIC MATRIX
  • RESEARCH & PROJECTS
    • DISCIPLINES >
      • LITERARY THEORY
      • COMPARATIVE LITERATURE
      • GLOBAL LITERARY STUDIES
      • HISTORY OF IDEAS
      • CULTURAL THEORY & ANALYSIS
    • AREAS >
      • ISLAMIC STUDIES
      • ARAB LITERATURE
      • MAGHREBIAN & WEST AFRICAN STUDIES
      • WEST EUROPEAN & EURO-MEDITERRANEAN LITERATURES
      • EAST EUROPEAN & POST-SOVIET LITERATURES
      • PORTUGUESE STUDIES
      • LUSOPHONE AFRICAN STUDIES
      • LATIN AMERICAN STUDIES
    • PERIODS >
      • MEDIEVAL & EARLY MODERN STUDIES
      • 19TH-CENTURY STUDIES
    • FIELDS >
      • TRANSCULTURAL HUMANITIES
      • TRANSCOLONIAL & TRANSINDIGENOUS STUDIES
      • MARITIME HUMANITIES
      • FEMINISMS, GENDER & QUEER STUDIES
      • EROTICISM & SEXUALITY STUDIES
      • PLANT & ANIMAL STUDIES
      • APOCALYPTIC STUDIES
    • TOPICS >
      • TRAVEL WRITING
      • WRITINGS ON ART
  • LIBRARY & THE WORLD
    • ARCTIC & SCANDINAVIA >
      • GREENLAND
      • ICELAND
      • NORWAY
      • SWEDEN
      • FINLAND
      • DENMARK
    • EASTERN EUROPE >
      • ESTONIA
      • LATVIA
      • LITHUANIA
      • RUSSIA
      • BELARUS
      • UKRAINE
      • POLAND
      • Forty Years of Travel in Poland
      • CZECH REPUBLIC
      • SLOVAKIA
      • HUNGARY
      • ROMANIA
      • MOLDOVA
    • WESTERN EUROPE >
      • IRELAND
      • SCOTLAND
      • GREAT BRITAIN
      • NETHERLANDS
      • BELGIUM
      • LUXEMBURG
      • GERMANY
      • AUSTRIA
      • LIECHTENSTEIN
      • SWITZERLAND
      • FRANCE
      • MIDI
      • ITALY
      • VENICE
      • SICILY
      • MALTA
      • CATALONIA
      • SPAIN
      • PORTUGAL
      • CANARY ISLANDS
    • THE BALKANS >
      • SLOVENIA
      • CROATIA
      • SERBIA
      • ALBANIA
      • BOSNIA & HERZEGOVINA
      • MONTENEGRO
      • BULGARIA
      • NORTH MACEDONIA
      • GREECE
    • CAUCASUS >
      • GEORGIA
      • ARMENIA
      • AZERBAIJAN
      • CHECHNYA & INGUSHETIA
      • DAGESTAN
      • A Ride across the Caucasus
    • MIDDLE EAST >
      • EGYPT
      • LEBANON
      • PALESTINE
      • ISRAEL
      • CYPRUS
      • TURKEY
      • CAPPADOCIA
      • KURDISTAN
      • SYRIA
      • IRAQ
      • KUWAIT
      • JORDAN
      • SAUDI ARABIA
      • QATAR
      • UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
      • BAHRAIN
      • OMAN
      • YEMEN
    • MAGHREB & SAHEL >
      • AL-ANDALUS
      • MOROCCO
      • TUNISIA
      • ALGERIA
      • LIBYA
      • SAHRAWI REPUBLIC
      • MAURITANIA
      • MALI
      • BURKINA FASO
      • NIGER
      • CHAD
      • SUDAN
      • FULANI WORLD
      • MANDINGA WORLD
    • WEST AFRICA >
      • SENEGAL
      • GAMBIA
      • CAPE VERDE
      • GUINEA-BISSAU
      • GUINEA
      • SIERRA LEONE
      • IVORY COAST
      • GHANA
      • SAO TOME & PRINCIPE
      • TOGO
      • BENIN
      • NIGERIA
      • CAMEROON
      • EQUATORIAL GUINEA
      • CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC
      • GABON
    • THE HORN OF AFRICA >
      • ETHIOPIA
      • ERITREA
      • DJIBOUTI
      • SOMALIA
    • THE SOUTH OF AFRICA >
      • CONGO
      • UGANDA
      • KENYA
      • RWANDA
      • BURUNDI
      • TANZANIA
      • ANGOLA
      • ZAMBIA
      • MALAWI
      • MOZAMBIQUE
      • ZIMBABWE
      • NAMIBIA
      • BOTSWANA
      • SOUTH AFRICA
      • LESOTHO
      • ESWATINI
    • INDIA & INDIAN OCEAN >
      • INDIA
      • NEPAL
      • BHUTAN
      • BANGLADESH
      • SRI LANKA
      • MALDIVES
      • SEYCHELLES
      • MAURITIUS
      • COMOROS
      • MADAGASCAR
    • SOUTH EAST ASIA >
      • LAOS
      • VIETNAM
      • CAMBODIA
      • MYANMAR
      • THAILAND
      • MALAYSIA
      • SINGAPORE
      • BRUNEI
      • INDONESIA
      • BALI
      • TIMOR
      • PHILIPPINES
    • IRAN & CENTRAL ASIA >
      • IRAN
      • AFGHANISTAN
      • PAKISTAN
      • UZBEKISTAN
      • TAJIKISTAN
      • KYRGYZSTAN
      • TURKMENISTAN
      • KAZAKHSTAN
      • TAKLAMAKAN & THE UYGHURS
    • NORTH & NORTH EAST ASIA >
      • CHUKOTKA & KAMCHATKA
      • SAKHA (YAKUTIA)
      • JAPAN
      • MANCHURIA
      • KOREA
      • BURYATIA
      • TUVA
      • MONGOLIA
      • CHINA
      • TIBET
    • NORTH AMERICA >
      • CANADA
      • UNITED STATES
    • MESOAMERICA >
      • MEXICO
      • GUATEMALA
      • BELIZE
      • EL SALVADOR
      • HONDURAS
      • NICARAGUA
      • COSTA RICA
      • PANAMA
    • THE CARIBBEAN >
      • CUBA
      • JAMAICA
      • HAITI
      • DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
      • PUERTO RICO
      • MARTINIQUE
      • TRINIDAD & TOBAGO
    • SOUTH AMERICA >
      • BRAZIL
      • COLOMBIA
      • VENEZUELA
      • GUYANA
      • SURINAME
      • ECUADOR
      • PERU
      • BOLIVIA
      • URUGUAY
      • PARAGUAY
      • ARGENTINA
      • CHILE
    • POLYNESIA >
      • EASTER ISLAND
      • TAHITI & FRENCH POLYNESIA
      • SAMOA
      • TONGA
    • MICRONESIA >
      • MARSHALL ISLANDS
      • PALAU
      • KIRIBATI
    • MELANESIA >
      • PAPUA NEW GUINEA
      • NEW CALEDONIA
      • VANUATU
      • FIJI
      • SOLOMON ISLANDS
    • AUSTRALASIA >
      • AUSTRALIA
      • NEW ZEALAND
    • ANTARCTICA >
      • EXPLORATION
  • AUTOBIOGRAPHICA & MARGINALIA
    • The Four Riders
    • The Flight of the Crimson Angel
    • Becoming undead
    • Transition
    • LIFESTYLE
    • ON LANGUAGES
    • FALCONRY
    • NATURE PHOTOGRAPHY >
      • PLANTS >
        • BOTANIC GARDENS
        • FORESTS
      • BUTTERFLIES
      • AMPHIBIANS & REPTILES
      • BIRDS
      • MAMMALS
      • WATER & AQUATIC LIFE
      • EARTH
      • LIGHT
    • GARDEN & DESERT. Erotic Journal
  • News & Events
    • Void in the making. RESEARCH BLOG
  • TEXTS
  • Contact